Rent Control By Declaration Of War: California’s SB 493 Would Cap Rents Whenever America Fights Abroad
A bill from State Senator Josh Becker would add war to the emergencies that trigger California’s 10 percent price-gouging cap, including on rents, adding another layer of controls to an already strained housing market
War As An Emergency At Home
California already has local rent control in many cities and a statewide cap on annual rent increases for most housing at least fifteen years old. A new bill would add a third layer, triggered not by local housing conditions but by American military action abroad. Reason’s Christian Britschgi examined the proposal on August 25 in a piece headlined California bill would cap rents during U.S.-involved war.
What SB 493 Would Do
SB 493, sponsored by State Senator Josh Becker of Menlo Park, would add war to the list of emergencies that can trigger California’s price-gouging law. That law caps price increases at ten percent on a range of goods and services, including rents, during a declared emergency. Under the bill, the governor could declare a state of emergency if Congress declares war, if the United States takes part in a United Nations peacekeeping operation or if the country is engaged in active military operations against any foreign state, whether or not war has been formally declared.
The bill includes some safeguards. Only a presidential or gubernatorial emergency declaration could start war-related controls. The attorney general would need to find a link between the war and a price increase. Caps would last thirty days and could be extended once, for a maximum of sixty days. Becker has said California should not become collateral damage in an international conflict, framing the bill as a response to rising prices, including at the gas pump.
The Problem With Price Caps
The impulse is understandable. When the United States is involved in a war, as it now is with Iran, prices can rise quickly, and families feel the pinch. But price controls do not create supply. They suppress the signal that tells producers to bring more goods, or housing, to market. When rents cannot rise, landlords have less incentive to maintain, upgrade or add units, and developers have less reason to build. Over time, controls reduce the quantity and quality of housing, which is precisely the opposite of what a state with a chronic housing shortage needs.
Price-gouging laws are often justified as short-term protections during natural disasters, when supply is suddenly disrupted. A war overseas is a different situation. It can last months or years. Even with time limits, a law that can be triggered repeatedly by military operations abroad creates ongoing uncertainty for anyone who owns or invests in rental housing.
Vague Definitions, Real Penalties
Landlords oppose the bill, Reason reports, arguing that its broad and vague definition of war would create compliance uncertainty and potential criminal liability for property owners who raise rents during an overseas conflict. What counts as active military operations against a foreign state? Does a limited air campaign qualify? A naval deployment? A peacekeeping mission? Laws that impose penalties should be clear. SB 493 leaves a great deal to interpretation, and in the case of price-gouging law, interpretation can mean prosecution.
There is also a constitutional dimension worth noting. Emergency powers, once granted, tend to be used. A governor who can declare an emergency whenever the United States is engaged in military operations abroad gains a significant lever over the state’s economy, triggered by events entirely outside California’s control. Libertarians have long warned about the expansion of emergency powers, which during the pandemic were used to impose sweeping restrictions with limited legislative oversight. SB 493 would extend that logic to foreign wars, which in recent decades have been almost continuous somewhere in the world.
The Housing Crisis Is A Supply Crisis
California’s housing problems are well documented. The state has some of the highest rents and home prices in the country, driven above all by a shortage of homes relative to demand. Zoning restrictions, lengthy environmental reviews, high construction costs and local opposition to new development have kept supply from keeping pace. Every serious analysis of the problem points to the need to build more.
Rent controls, whether permanent or emergency-based, do nothing to address that shortage. At best, they redistribute the pain, protecting some existing tenants while making it harder for newcomers to find housing. At worst, they reduce supply further, as owners convert rentals to other uses or hold units off the market.
The Coastal Housing Squeeze
Nowhere is the housing shortage more visible than along the coast. Surf towns from San Clemente to Santa Cruz have seen rents climb beyond the reach of the people who work in them: surf instructors, shapers, lifeguards, restaurant staff, teachers. Many have been pushed inland, commuting long distances on expensive gas. The answer for those communities is more housing, built faster, not another layer of controls that discourages anyone from building or renting.
A Better Response To Wartime Prices
If lawmakers want to help Californians cope with higher prices during wartime, there are better tools. Suspending or cutting state fuel taxes would directly lower costs at the pump. Streamlining housing approvals would bring new supply online. Reducing regulatory barriers to energy production and imports would ease price spikes. Each of these approaches works with markets rather than against them.
SB 493 reflects a recurring instinct in Sacramento: when prices rise, cap them. History, from gasoline lines in the 1970s to the shortages produced by rent control in cities around the world, shows where that instinct leads. California does not need rent control by declaration of war. It needs the freedom to build.