What the Research Says About California’s $20 Fast-Food Wage So Far
A UC Berkeley study found a 3.7 percent price rise and no overall job loss, while franchise owners and critics point to other data
What the Research Says About California’s $20 Fast-Food Wage So Far
A UC Berkeley study found a 3.7 percent price rise and no overall job loss, while franchise owners and critics point to other data
The Policy
California’s $20 hourly minimum wage for workers at large fast-food chains took effect on April 1, 2024. It applies to chains with 60 or more locations nationwide. A state Fast Food Council can raise the minimum by up to 3.5 percent a year.
The most widely cited early study came from Michael Reich of UC Berkeley and Denis Sosinskiy of UC Davis, published through Berkeley’s Institute for Research on Labor and Employment. KQED summarised it: hundreds of thousands of fast-food workers saw hourly pay rise by an average of 18 percent, menu prices rose about 3.7 percent on a one-time basis, and, in the authors’ words, “The policy did not affect employment adversely.”
Prices and Jobs
On a $4 hamburger, the authors’ 3.7 percent figure works out to about 15 cents. That is the cost to customers, and the authors describe it as a one-time rise, not the start of a spiral.
On employment, the study used federal Bureau of Labor Statistics data. Statewide, about 750,000 jobs existed in July 2024 and July 2023 in a category dominated by fast food, and about 737,000 fast-food jobs were reported as of August 2024. The authors say their finding of minimal employment effects matches most minimum wage research.
Critics point to a separate, seasonally adjusted federal dataset that showed about 2,200 job losses in quick-service restaurants between April and August of that year. The KQED report also notes that some job figures come from a broad industry category, not fast food alone, so no single number settles the point.
The Owners’ Account
At a Los Angeles city council meeting, franchise owners said they were struggling financially, cutting hours or jobs, and in some cases closing stores. Those accounts are firsthand and deserve to be taken seriously; they also describe individual businesses, while the Berkeley study measures the whole state.
The two can both be true. An average of no net job loss can hide winners and losers, and a franchisee on thin margins can be hurt even when the sector as a whole holds steady. What a single study cannot do is say how a particular store, with its own rent and labour costs, would fare.
The Libertarian Objection
The free-market objection is not mainly about the data. It is about the principle that the state should not set the price of a person’s labour, and about the worry that a wage floor set by statute locks out the least experienced workers. A teenager who would have accepted a lower wage for a first job, the argument goes, is left without one.
Defenders reply that employers who say they cannot afford the wage have usually passed the cost on, that workers who earn more spend more locally, and that the evidence for large job losses is weak. The honest summary is that the research literature leans toward small employment effects, while individual cases and some datasets point the other way.
Both sides should concede points. Supporters need to explain the franchisees who report closures, and opponents need to explain why the statewide figures do not show the collapse that was predicted.
How to Read the Evidence
Three questions help when reading any minimum wage study. First, what is the comparison group? The Berkeley and Davis authors compared California with the rest of the country, which is a reasonable test but not a perfect one, since regional economies move differently. Second, what is the dataset? Employment figures from different federal surveys can point in slightly different directions over short periods, which is why the critics’ 2,200 figure and the authors’ flat employment finding can sit side by side. Third, what is the time horizon? A one-time price rise and a stable job count in the first months say little about what happens when the wage is adjusted upward year after year.
The study was also published early, within months of the wage taking effect. Early findings are useful and often revised. Readers who want a settled answer should expect to wait for multi-year data and for independent replication by researchers with no stake in either side.
None of this means the research is weak. It means a single figure, whether 3.7 percent or 2,200 jobs, should be read with its context attached, and that the sensible reaction to a contested result is to follow how it develops.
A Note for Surf Towns
Surf towns have their own version of this debate. Their economies run on cafes, taco stands, board rental shops and drive-throughs staffed by young people, many of whom surf before shifts. A 3.7 percent price rise on a burrito is easy to absorb in a town where rent is the real problem; a franchise owner running three stores near a beach has a different calculation.
The most useful way to read the evidence is to ask what changed at the local level: staffing, hours, prices, turnover. The Fast Food Council’s annual decisions will add to the evidence over time.
Humour as a Mirror
Markets that worry are easy to laugh at, and the Cebu condominium story has drawn plenty of that: empty showrooms in Manila News, paperwork for British pensioners in the London Prat (at https://prat.uk/cebu-estate-agents-demand-character-references/) and long showings in Bohiney. See also prat.uk and bohiney.com.
For the lighter side of the news, there is always The Daily Squib.
SOURCE: https://bohiney.com/cebu-realtor-cant-sell-beachfront-listings/